Rational Faith

Don't get your Theology from an Atheist



There are a lot of falsehoods, misinformation and outright lies on the internet. But there is also truth on the internet so you must be careful to discern the truth from the falsehoods, the fact from the fiction. In this post I want to highlight a good rule of thumb to consider when people start discussing theology or Christianity or religion with you: Here's the good advice: Don't get your theology from an atheist.

This should be obvious, but to clarify, there's a saying that has been going around online - at least on Twitter - that imparts a valuable piece of wisdom: "Only a fool would allow his enemies to educate his children."


The wisdom there is obvious. Clearly you don't want someone opposed to your belief system to instruct your kids on what is true and what is false. What Christian church would allow an avowed Satanist to teach Sunday school? We will use that same wisdom, that same insight to debunk the following objections to Christianity found also online:


So this apparent atheist Ben Watkins (atheist - based on his clearly atheistic positions and the fact that he hosts "@RealAtheology) questions  these three fundamental truths about Christianity:

The Trinity
The Incarnation
The Atonement

And he is affirmed by another atheist going by the name of @InternetAtheists. I will not do an in depth exposition of these doctrines here on why the atheists are wrong because I've already done that in my five part series on "Knowledge of the Holy One" (The title references Prov 9.10; 30.3), which starts with part 1 "Jesus the Holy One Revealed", and covers all these topics. Here I will merely give a brief response using logic - which atheists are supposed to be good at - before moving on:

Re: The Trinity:
Atheists believe they can treat an infinite, unbounded God in the same manner they treat a finite, bounded person. They believe they can treat a spiritual being (whom they deny exists) the same as they treat a physical person. The former is a category error, the latter an appeal to ignorance.

Re: The Incarnation
There is nothing logically inconsistent with an eternal God entering his own temporal creation. There is also nothing inconsistent with the human messiah dying (both physically - his body died, and spiritually - he was separated from God while he hung on the Cross ("My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" -  Matt 27.46) These are likely concepts an atheist is not familiar with. If atheists claim to know the incarnation is not possible, they are simply making another appeal to ignorance. How can they know what's possible or impossible for an omnipotent God whom they deny exists? So again, you don't want to get your theology from an atheist.

Re: The Atonement
His statement "no one can die for another's sin" is both a fallacious appeal to consequence (he clearly doesn't like that someone can). It's also a fallacious appeal to authority. Has he made the laws - moral and otherwise - that govern the universe? Does he appeal to the person who claims he has (that would be God). Both answers are no - and thus he has no qualified authority to backup his claim. So here the atheist is like Satan, wanting to play God (Is 14:12-14) and appeal to his own authority to determine what is and is not allowable; he wants to determine what is justice and what is not. But he has no logical basis for doing so. (Or any other basis for that matter.)

Satan was cast out of heaven for his blasphemous arrogance and pride in wanting to "...ascend above the tops of the clouds; I will make myself like the Most High." (Is 14.14) Since the atheist is likewise not God, he has no authority to say if an atonement is possible or not, and what will or will not suffice for an atonement if it is possible. If he wants to appeal to some concept of "justice" the question is then, what "justice?" Atheist high priest Richard Dawkins says "The universe we observe has precisely the properties we should expect if there is, at bottom, no design, no purpose, no evil, no good, nothing but blind, pitiless indifference." If there is no good or evil and only indifference, then clearly there can be no "justice."

If any atheist continues with such pretensions and arrogance of knowing better than God, and denying those fundamental tenets of the the faith, they too will be cast into outer darkness and spend an eternity with Satan and the angels who followed him. (Matt 25.41)

But again, the point I want focus on is not the theology, but the foolishness of getting your theology from an atheist or anyone other than a mature, grounded-in-the-faith Christian.

God is not Bound by Theological Misunderstandings

Following are false concepts that have been held to be true by those who don't know either God or the scriptures, or they wouldn't be so foolish as to believe such falsehoods. I point them out as illustrations that you should not get your theology from atheists and others who don't know God or the scriptures - or who deny them.

The Ark of the Covenant

After the Babylonians captured the southern kingdom of Judah where the temple of God was located (with the ark of the covenant located in the temple) around 587 BC, the ark disappeared. While there are a number of places that are suspected to be where the ark is currently located[1], no one is sure. Many have sought the ark, thinking they can gain mystical, magical powers from it. As one documentary put it:

"The ark of the covenant is is a golden chest described in the book of Exodus as containing the tablets of stone on which the ten commandments were written. As well as Aaron's rod, a jar of manna, and the first torah scroll. It's said to possess enormous power. Enough to destroy the walls of Jericho and to kill anyone who touches it."[2]

Why do they believe they can gain magical powers from the ark? Because they misunderstand the accounts of the walls of Jericho falling (Josh 6.1-5) and the account Uzzah, who reached out to steady the ark and was struck down.( 2 Sam 6.6-7) Since they either don't know the word of God or don't believe it, they don't understand that the walls of Jericho fell because God had announced he would give Jericho into the hands of the Israelites, and Uzzah was struck down because sinful man cannot enter the presence of the holy God without the covering of an atonement.

Since they don't understand these things, like one who doesn't understand science they think it's magic. But like science, once understood, it is very straight forward: The power behind the ark of the covenant is not magic, it is the power of God directed by the will of God. Apart from those things, the ark of the covenant is just another ornate box. Don't get your theology or your  understanding of the ark from those who deny God and believe in magic - like atheists. That is an obvious and grave mistake.

The Spear of Destiny

But when they came to Jesus and found that he was already dead, they did not break his legs.
Instead, one of the soldiers pierced Jesus' side with a spear, bringing a sudden flow of blood and water.

John 19.33-34

The spear thrust into the side of Jesus to prove he was dead is known as "The Spear of Destiny." Like the ark, it is supposed to contain enormous power:

"The spear of destiny is said to be none other than the spear which had pierced the side of Jesus Christ as he hung on the cross. Myth says it was wielded by a Roman centurion named Longinus."[3]

Legend also says the blood from Christ dripping down the spear fell on Longinus eye - which had a cataract - and was instantly cured.

The spear later comes to the emperor Charlemagne -

"Charlemagne carries it into battle. He's invincible as long as it's in his hands."[4]
Sidney D. Kirkpatric

"It becomes a talisman for conquerors for military force. It is a military image that it has of vanquishing foes."[5]
Robert Feather

Thus the legend is born which Hitler foolishly believed and connived and stole his way into gaining the spear. Obviously it didn't help Hitler - the allies won in spite of Hitler possessing the spear.

Once again, God is not bound by false understanding of either theology or magic. So once again, don't get your theology from those who believe in the power of magic and thus believe in the alleged magic of the spear - and consequently disbelieve in the power of God - like atheists.

Theology is not Fiat Magic

Thor's Hammer

Any Marvel fans out there? Remember the scene from Thor - the first one:

Thor acts foolishly, and his father Odin - head of the Norse pantheon is disgusted and banishes Thor and strips him of his powers. Then in his anger, he enchants Thor's hammer saying:

"Whosoever holds this hammer
If he be worthy, shall possess the power of Thor."

Video: Odin casts out Thor and enchants Thor's hammer Mjolnir

Atheists apparently believe in making theological statements the way Odin enchants Thor's hammer: by fiat. They simply make a statement and expect it to be true.

But reality is not based on Marvel comics or Norse mythology. And atheists have no power to make fiat statements like the ones made above and expect them to be true. Odin's enchantment of Thor's hammer is a fiat statement based on a merger of comic book drama and Norse mythology and a belief in magic. But Christian theology is not based on fiat statements from either comic books or atheists or magic. Christian theology is based on the word of God.

So, just as you don't want Satanists teaching Sunday school, don't get your theology from atheists. And particularly atheists who act like they have the power of  the false god Odin to make false fiat statements about that which they deny. Instead, go to the source: the word of God as recorded in the Holy Scriptures.

A final thought: scripture warns against getting advice from mediums and spiritists. The same warning goes for getting theological advice from  atheists:

"When men tell you to consult mediums and spiritists, who whisper and mutter, should not a people inquire of their God?"
Isaiah 8.19


Duane Caldwell | May 13, 2022


1. Suspected locations of the Ark of the Covenant:

a. Rosslyn Chapel, Scotland
b. Rennes Le Chateau, France
c. Elephantine Island, Egypt
d. Axum, Ethiopia
e. Jerusalem, Israel (hidden)

Forbidden History - "The Real Ark of the Covenant", documentary, 2015
Solving History With Olly Steeds - "The Ark of the Covenant", documentary, 2010


2. Forbidden History - "The Real Ark Of The Covenant", AHC documentary, 2015

3. (Narrator) Myth Hunters: "Hitler and the Spear of Destiny", Documentary, 2012

Sidney D. Kirkpatric, Author, Hitler's Holy Relics, Ref from:
Myth Hunters: "Hitler and the Spear of Destiny", Documentary, 2012

5. Robert Feather, Author, A Clash of Steal, Ref from:
Myth Hunters: "Hitler and the Spear of Destiny", Documentary, 2012


The Serpent in the Garden - from The Creation Museum, KY - Picture Duane Caldwell